Superheroes |
The animated Small Foot may or may not break out at the end of the month. We’ll find out in November whether Fantastic Beasts is a one-time curiosity or something that folks will want to follow to the end of its reported five-film lifespan. However, the Dream Factory is having a solid year. They are mostly doing it without conventional sequels or franchise faire. Steven Spielberg’s Ready Player One pulled $588 million worldwide and they pushed Dwayne Johnson’s Rampage to $426m worldwide on a $125m budget, making it the second-biggest video game adaptation ever. Even Teen Titans Go! To the Movies grossed $46m worldwide on a $10m budget.
Their comedy slate (Game Night, Ocean’s 8, Tag and Crazy Rich Asians) has been relatively solid, both commercially and critically. Yes, Tomb Raider underperformed in North America (but made $273 million worldwide on a $94m budget), Life of the Party was a slightly underwhelming Melissa McCarthy vehicle ($65m on a $30m budget) and Paddington 2 ($40m domestic) should have moved to a later date after it went from Weinstein to Warner at almost the last minute. But, barring a fluke with A Star Is Born and a whiff with Crimes of Grindelwald, WB has succeeded in making Aquaman almost irrelevant in terms of the studio’s big picture.
That’s not to say that Warner Bros./Time Warner Inc. should cancel the DC Films franchise or any such nonsense. I’m optimistic for the Jason Momoa flick if only because I believe in James Wan, and Shazam looks like a nice balance between “lighter, more kid-friendly” while still taking place in the previously grimdark DC Films continuity. And yeah, I’m sure Wonder Woman 1984 will at least be a solid hit whether or not it breaks out as big as its predecessor. After that, whether or not Joker justifies itself, it’s an open question. But here’s the good news: WB no longer “needs” the DC Films franchise.
If the last several months are any indication, they are back where they were several years ago. As I wrote way back in early 2014, the studio had a big enough and diverse enough slate of movies that they didn’t need to bet the farm on a DC Comics-based cinematic universe. When Gravity is earning over $700 million worldwide and winning Oscars, We’re the Millers tops $150m domestic and Magic Mike is snagging a $39m debut weekend, then the notion of an expensive and time-consuming DC Films franchise being a do-or-die proposition is not only foolhardy but counterintuitive. But press ahead they did, to their overall detriment.
Whether it was because the success of The Avengers had Time Warner shareholders demanding their own superhero cinematic universe, or whether Chris Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy kept explicit interconnectivity on the backburner until Marvel had already done their thing, Warner Bros. eventually went ahead and announced a slate of interconnected superhero movies in October of 2014. It has been a bumpy and complicated road, full of critical disappointments, relative smash hits and a deeply unpleasant media narrative painting the WB executives as the worst kind of reactionary micromanagers. As feared, the struggles over the DC Films flicks has colored everything else at the studio.
The rumors, speculations and misadventures concerning the production, release and reception of Batman v Superman, Suicide Squad and Justice League came to define the studio. Never mind that Dunkirk became the biggest-grossing World War II movie of all time while snagging rave reviews and a number of Oscar nods. Never mind that American Sniper bagged a $107m Fri-Mon debut weekend and eventually topped $350m domestic. Never mind that six of last 13 live-action originals that have topped $450m worldwide were released domestically and/or overseas by Warner Bros. Justice League bombed and Suicide Squad was re-edited by a trailer company. WB was doomed, even while It topped $700m worldwide.
Here’s what the successes of Crazy Rich Asians, The Meg and The Nun have bought the studio: They can treat the DC Films franchise as just another IP among a number of would-be event movies. It can be no more or less important than Fantastic Beasts or their Godzilla/King Kong monster franchises, big movies that earned good reviews and didn’t remotely reek of executive micromanagement. They can make whichever of the 8,194 announced DC Films flicks currently in development as they so choose, with no more or less pressure than the decision to greenlight The Trench or Ocean’s 9. because they really do have a choice.
The DC Comics franchise should never have been treated, either by the studio or by the media, as an “all eggs in one basket” situation. And now, it’s almost impossible to look at WB’s 2018 slate and argue that Aquaman will be anything other than just another potential tentpole flick. That’s good for the studio, good for the industry and, I would argue, good for those who want good-to-great DC Comics movies. They can be both the folks who make DC Films movies and JK Rowling fantasies alongside The Nun, American Sniper and Magic Mike not because they have to be, but because they choose to be.
Follow Us
Were this world an endless plain, and by sailing eastward we could for ever reach new distances